Empathy linked to responses, but narrative messages did not outperform…

Who Connects with Narrative Messages? Empathic Concern and Identification as Individual-Level Pathways of Response to Narrative Messages in Cannabis-Impaired Driving Prevention.

Health communication • • Highly Relevant
🤖

AI Summary

This two-wave online experiment tested whether empathic concern affects responses to video messages about driving under the influence of cannabis (DUIC), and whether this relationship operates through identification with a protagonist. Participants were adult cannabis users who drive and were randomly assigned to narrative or expository DUIC messages, or to a control narrative about skin cancer prevention. The eligible baseline sample was 483; follow-up analyses included 264–290 participants.

The message format had no overall effect on any outcome. Among those who viewed narrative DUIC messages, greater empathic concern was associated with stronger identification and transportation. When accounting for overlap with transportation, identification was negatively associated with DUIC intentions after exposure and at follow-up, and with DUIC behaviors at follow-up. These findings describe associations and who may respond to narrative messages; they do not show that narrative messages outperform expository ones or establish that empathic concern causes safer driving. This is an abstract-based summary; the study cannot establish the messages’ real-world preventive effectiveness.

💡 Key Findings

1
Narrative and expository DUIC messages showed no overall differences on any measured outcome.
High
90%
2
Among viewers of narrative DUIC messages, empathic concern was positively related to protagonist identification and transportation.
High
80%
3
Accounting for overlap with transportation, identification was negatively associated with DUIC intentions after exposure and at follow-up, and with DUIC behaviors at follow-up; this does not establish causation.
High
80%

📄 Original Abstract

Narrative messages may help audiences engage with content and identify with characters, thereby enhancing persuasion. This study tests whether empathic concern - a stable other-oriented affective facet of empathy - shapes responses to narrative messages through identification with the protagonist. A two-wave between-subjects online experiment tested video messages targeting driving under the influence of cannabis (DUIC), among adult cannabis users who drive. Participants were randomly assigned to narrative or expository DUIC messages, or a control condition (a skin cancer prevention narrative), all featuring the same protagonist. Message format had no overall effect on any outcome. Among participants who viewed narrative DUIC prevention messages (eligible baseline sample: N = 483; follow-up analytic samples: N = 264-290), empathic concern was positively related to identification and transportation. Identification, once its overlap with transportation was accounted for, was negatively associated with DUIC intentions post-exposure and at follow-up, and with DUIC behaviors at follow-up. Empathic concern may shape responses to narrative messages about risky driving, through identification. Results illustrate who responds to narrative messages about DUIC, rather than whether narrative messages outperform expository ones, and indicate that empathic concern is related to, but conceptually distinct from, identification, with implications for message design and for narrative theory.

Explore More Research

Stay informed about the latest cannabis science.

Your stash, decoded.